A M E R I C A N   D E N T A L   A S S O C I A T I O N

Georgia Dental Association

Central  District  Dental Society


Efforts towards
BMPs - Best Practice Management - for
Amalgam in Dental-Office Wastewater

AmalgamSeparators-HinmanDisplay20090319.jpg

Hinman Dental Meeting 2009

AmalgamSeparators-HinmanDisplay20090319b.jpg


Also

Paticipated in a conference call on Wednesday, March 25, 2009, 4:30 p.m., Central Time, for one hour.
 

Dr. John Findley, ADA president,  hosted the call. 
Mr. Jerry Bowman, public affairs counsel, Department of State Government Affairs was the lead presenter. 
Heard state perspectives from:
 
Ms. Vicki Wilbers, executive director
Missouri Dental Association
 
Mr. Bill Zepp, executive director
Oregon Dental Association


Why did the ADA enter into this?
What are the risks?
What are the benefits of actively pursuing voluntary separator usage?
Why is the ADA doing this now?
What can states do to make this work?
What resources are available from the ADA?
What’s next?
 
any questions:::
Ron Polaniecki  polanieckir@ada.org
Manager
Dental Society Services
312.440.2599

Dr Percy discussed - we need easier Recycling.  It is currently too difficult to find a recycler.  And fees are high. 
Can we get Fed Gov to help reward recycling? .




Overview




Amalgam separators are devices designed to remove amalgam waste particles from dental office wastewater. The placement and removal of dental amalgam restorations generates amalgam waste particles that can be suctioned into the dental unit vacuum line and discharged into the public sewer system.

The effort to reduce amalgam waste discharge from the dental office is the result of increasing pressure facing local wastewater treatment plants to reduce the concentration of mercury in effluent from their plants and the concentration of mercury in sludge. The ADA's Best Management Practices for amalgam waste include the use of amalgam separators. Although there is no national regulation requiring the installation of amalgam separators in U.S. dental offices, state and local requirements exist in some areas. - (information from ADA)













(Free) Amalgam Recyclers:
None

 











Amalgam Position Paper of the GDA adopted 1-2008 pages 181-187 - also in 8-2008 BOT reports part 2 - page46/101


ADA list of accepted Amalgam Separators products:
http://www.amerdental.com/product.php?product_ID=AL-42&major=&minor=&sub=&base =#




  Mississippi BMP

NY-Vermont  BMP



North Carolina- Dept or Environment and Natural Resources - Division of Pollution Prevention and Environmental Assistance (DPPEA)
http://www.p2pays.org/
http://www.p2pays.org/mercury/






Paul Kenworthy  says Vermont madated separaters as of this past January.  There was some grumbling, but everything seems to be working ok now.  

Vermont State Dental Society
http://www.vsds.org/
1-800-640-5099



 


 
Subject: RE: BMP for amalgam

http://www.p2pays.org/ref/18/17432.pdf

The Environmentally Responsible Dental Office:
A Guide to Proper Waste Management in Dental Offices


Paul Kenworthy (Vermont)
http://www.kenworthydental.com/cosmetic_dentist_essex_jct/index.asp


and Bob Shaw (Washington)

Dr. Robert Shaw, DDS: said that the use of mercury amalgam is not controversial:

http://www.toxicteeth.org/rebuttal.cfm

  





Clear Tubes to collect Amalgam here:
http://www.theamalgamcollector.com/?refresh=1

  






Mercury-Based Chlorine Plants Rival Coal-Burning Power Plants as Mercury Polluters

http://oceana.org/index.php?id=339
As the extent of mercury contamination in our environment, our bodies and our food comes to light, concern over mercury pollution is increasing. While most media and public attention has focused on coal-burning power plants, most people remain unaware that a small subset of the chlorine industry makes a major - and completely preventable - contribution to the global mercury crisis.




 
 

Fish Consumption Advice



Human Health Studies




http://www.oceana.org/fileadmin/oceana/uploads/mercury/poisonplants_1/Georgia_Mercury_Report.pdf
has graphic of top 10 mercury company polluters - top is GaPower- Plant Scherer

Mercury Contamination
This Olin plant has leaked and released enough mercury into its surrounding environment to qualify as a
RCRA Corrective Action Site.201Throughout 2003 and 2004, the plant failed to monitor waste releases to
groundwater as required by its RCRA permit.202

Additionally, LCP, a division of Hanlin Group (Allied) operated a mercury-cell plant in Brunswick, GA from
1957 to 1994. The Brunswick site, the majority of which is tidal marsh, is a Superfund site.203 EPA estimates
that more than 380,000 pounds (over 170,000 kg) of mercury were “lost” in the area during the period of
operation of the plant.204 Mercury and polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) have been detected in aquatic life at
levels sufficient to produce a ban on commercial fishing in these areas and a seafood consumption advisory
for part of the river and all of the creek.205

2004 Mercury-Related Fish Advisories206
Georgia issued 178 fish consumption advisories – relating to 40 different rivers and 34 lakes and ponds.
Near the Olin plant, in the Savannah River Basin, there were 24 advisories, affecting five rivers and seven
lakes and ponds.

In the Purvis Creek area near the Brunswick Superfund site, Georgia currently recommends eating no more
than one meal per week of red drum, and one meal per month of blue crab, spotted seatrout, Southern kingfish
(whiting), and sheepshead, due to mercury contamination.207These recommendations are based on data
collected in 2002, three years after EPA excavated the vast majority of on-site soil and waste piles.208The
previous year’s (2003) consumption guidelines based on ecological data collected in 1995 were more restrictive
(for example, it was not safe to eat red drum), which indicates that mercury levels may have decreased
following the cleanup.209  The state also has issued mercury warnings for the whole estuary (St. Simon’s Estuary).
Georgia, Florida and South Carolina jointly issued an advisory recommending that no one eat king mackerel
more than 39 inches long (15 –17 lbs.), and that pregnant women, nursing mothers and children restrict their
consumption of smaller fish (33 – 39 inches) to one meal per month. The states also recommended that other
adults limit their consumption of smaller King Mackerel (33 – 39 inches) to one meal per week.






From: "neill herring" <neillherring@earthlink.net>
Subject: Fw:  6pm radio show on GPB--message from Savannah Riverkeeper
 8-14-08 @ 5:30pm
 

 

Good afternoon all,

   I wanted to encourage you to listen to the Georgia Gazette Radio Show tomorrow broadcasting at 6:35 am, 8:35am, and 6pm on Georgia Public Radio. The story Friday is about our battle against Olin Corporation on the Savannah River, and the pending legislation that would end the controversy for good.  Many people associate mercury pollution in the United States with coal burning energy plants, and they are the #1 source, but it is much lesser known that the #2 source of mercury is from only 5 chlor-alkali plants (produce chlorine using mercury) Our plant in Augusta estimates (at a low #) a loss of fugitive mercury emissions that exceed 700lbs a year. I continue to believe that if we all stood together in defiance of these companies (and their extremely outdated and inefficient manufacturing processes) we could eliminate the #2 source of mercury completely.

 

   Sorry for the soap box, but I do hope all of you will have a chance to listen to the story and support the legislation that would end this madness once and for all.  If you would like to learn more about the issue www.oceana.org is the best place to fill you in. Well that, and I am never short of information and love to talk peoples ears off about the subject. Hope all is well, TB

 

Tonya Bonitatibus

(706) 755-4839

tbonitatibus@comcast.net

Savannah Riverkeeper (and Oceana)